Wild at Heart Review: A Critical Examination

John Eldredge's 'Wild at Heart' is a book that has gained widespread popularity among Christian men, encouraging them to be bold, adventurous, and risk-takers. However, beneath its inspiring veneer lies a flawed theology that undermines the very principles it seeks to promote.

For Eldredge, God is portrayed as a risk-taker and adventure-seeker at heart. While this may seem appealing, it presents a confusing and unbiblical picture of God's nature. The book is riddled with very significant problems that undermine its entire theological foundation.

One such issue is the way Eldredge elevates human experience above Scripture. He suggests that God uses books like 'Wild at Heart' in spite of their theological flaws, which is a flawed understanding of biblical authority. Rather than submitting to God's Word, men are now more likely to watch clips from movies like Braveheart and model themselves after William Wallace, a rugged and adventurous figure.

As a result, Bible studies have taken a backseat, replaced by DVD/VCR players and other forms of entertainment. This is a far cry from the biblical mandate to 'study to show yourself approved' (2 Timothy 2:15). Eldredge's book has inadvertently contributed to a culture that values experience over Scripture, which diminishes God's glory and name.

Furthermore, Eldredge's defense of his book as a tool for spiritual growth is flawed. Rather than relying on the written word of God, men are now more likely to look to human examples like William Wallace or even fictional characters like Maximus from Gladiator (2000). This approach not only contradicts Scripture but also diminishes the authority and sufficiency of God's Word.

In conclusion, while 'Wild at Heart' may have inspired many Christian men to be bold and adventurous, its theological flaws are significant enough to undermine its overall message. Rather than elevating human experience above Scripture, we should strive for a deeper understanding of God's Word and its application in our lives. Only then can we truly be 'wild at heart' for Christ.

Wild at heart review john eldredge